Image
Credit: Brady Doak

Modelling restorative economies

Determining the benefits of small-scale, community-based marine restoration initiatives

Project LeaderDurationBudget
Eva Siwicka (University of Auckland)August 2021 – June 2023$437,218

Overview

Successful marine restoration projects from around the world all share the same pattern: the key to their success is the community-led ‘ground-up’ approach, because people are more invested in the outcome.

In Aotearoa New Zealand, many iwi and community groups champion and lead initiatives to restore degraded marine environments. However, gaining support from government and/or investors is often difficult because the benefits (social, ecological, and economic) are hard to quantify.

To bridge this gap, we are synthesising and integrating knowledge from across our research to provide baseline information and guidance for communities, iwi, businesses, and investors looking to engage in marine restoration initiatives.

This involves the evolution of a Bayes Net model first developed by our Measuring and mapping ecosystem services project to develop a social-ecological framework. Based on three core components of ecological recovery processes, social processes and sustainability, this framework will:

  • model the probability of success of the recovery-focused action(s)
  • determine the synergies and trade-offs of a restorative intervention
  • provide context to economic analyses and investment opportunities.

We are incorporating information into this framework from the following active projects:

Ecological responses to cumulative effects – research into recovery processes and bottlenecks is helping us to develop as a foundation to identify the social-ecological benefits of active restoration and where these benefits are most likely to gather.

Awhi Mai Awhi Atu – weaving together mātauranga, kaitiaki and ecology, this project is determining the cultural benefits and opportunities of restorative actions and the development of relevant infrastructure to rural Māori economies. We are linking mātauranga and tohu (fundamental ecological knowledge) to these cultural benefits and opportunities.

Restorative marine economies – a review of current restoration practices in Aotearoa New Zealand provides sustainability and economic indicators that will allow a range of potential investors to assess the viability of restorative economy projects. We are drawing on the ways that investors consider benefits and costs of restoration.

In addition to the Bayes Net model, we will produce a social-ecological network analysis (SNA) map to help iwi and communities navigate bureaucratic structures, and link current policy and plans to ecologically and culturally feasible recovery plans that attract potential investors and businesses.

Growing the restorative marine economy sector and delivering social and environmental benefits using ecosystem-based management will contribute to transitioning to a blue economy in Aotearoa New Zealand.

Research Team

Eva Siwicka (University of Auckland)
Simon Thrush (University of Auckland)
Kura Paul-Burke (University of Waikato/MUSA Environmental)
Nick Lewis (University of Auckland)
Sandra Cortés Acosta (EnviroStrat)
Karen Fisher (University of Auckland)
Eric Jorgensen (Ocean Bay Farms)

Related News

Project proposal

307 KB | pdf

Location

This project is not location specific.

Tools & Resources

This project has produced or contributed to:

Ecosystem-based management in Aotearoa New Zealand (UN Ocean Decade Laboratory)
Presentation
This webinar presentation and discussion was led by early-career researchers working with Sustainable Seas. March 2022 (1hr45m + 15m Q&A)
View
Te Au o Te Moana story series
Video
This series aims to whakamana (empower) the voices of researchers, co-developers, Māori partners and communities of research and practice associated with Sustainable Seas and their relationship with the moana.
View
Seafood: Tools, resources and research
Summary
This is a research round-up of our tools, resources and research that support an ecosystem-based management (EBM) approach to the seafood industry (July 2022)
View
Healthy coastal ecosystems
Graphic
This infographic provides overview of the factors required for healthy coastal ecosystems (October 2023)
View
Modelling factors that influence community initiatives to restore marine environments
Summary
Summary of social, ecological, and economic factors connected to community-based initiatives to restore the marine environment (June 2024)
View

Related projects & activities

Image
Credit: Hamish McCormick
Policy and legislation for EBM
We are developing a research base for policy makers, Māori and stakeholders to navigate the legislative, policy and practice constraints surrounding EBM and any changes required to enable it.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Kura Paul Burke
Awhi Mai Awhi Atu: Enacting a kaitiakitanga-based approach to EBM
This project combines mātauranga Māori, science and local kaitiakitanga to better understand the culturally and socially important species in Ōhiwa Harbour.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Ōhiwa Harbour, Sustainable Seas
Ecological responses to cumulative effects
This project brings together mātauranga Māori and science to develop new knowledge about cumulative effects
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Leigh Tait NIWA
Measuring ecosystem services and assessing impacts
We developed new ways to measure and map the ecosystem services provided by marine ecosystems.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Paula Blackett
Testing participatory processes for marine management
We identified the best ways to involve interested parties in decision-making about the governance and management of marine environments.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Tipping points in ecosystem structure, function and services
We investigated how marine ecosystems respond to change, and identified tipping points, risks and ways of managing them.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Ngāti Kahungunu Inc on Te Matau-a-Maui, Waka Hourua © Desna Whaanga-Schollum, 2013
Indigenising the blue economy
Addressing key barriers that currently prevent Māori from using their marine resources in a more culturally relevant, economically impactful, and environmentally sustainable manner
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Greg Lois Nunes
Restorative marine economies
Encouraging restorative economies in Aotearoa New Zealand’s marine spaces
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Participatory processes for marine ecosystem restoration
We examined how the Kaituna River re-diversion strategy was developed, to identify success factors in stakeholder and iwi engagement that could be applied in other marine resource contexts.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Navigating marine social-ecological systems
We aimed to identify and/or improve our understanding of institutional, social and cultural factors that need to be incorporated into EBM for it to be successfully used to manage Aotearoa New Zealand’s marine resources.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Dave Allen NIWA
Development of valuation frameworks and principles
We identified frameworks and principles for recognising the multiple values of the marine environment to support EBM.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Mauri Moana, Mauri Tangata, Mauri Ora
We explored ways to assess the values New Zealanders hold for the marine environment.
More
This project has produced or contributed to