Image
Innovation Fund

Participatory processes for marine ecosystem restoration

We examined how the Kaituna River re-diversion strategy was developed, to identify success factors in stakeholder and iwi engagement that could be applied in other marine resource contexts.

Project LeaderDurationBudget
Patrick Barrett (University of Waikato)October 2016 – September 2018 $293,000

Overview

A long process of engagement between the Bay of Plenty Regional Council and the community has resulted in the partial re-diversion of the Kaituna River into the Maketū estuary. The aim was to restore estuarine habitats by reducing sedimentation, re-establishing wetland and salt marsh environments, and replenishing shellfish and other fish stocks. 

Our research examined interactions between the council and the community that led to this outcome. We interviewed key individuals and groups involved in planning and designing the project to identify principles and practices for effective community engagement. We spoke with iwi and hapū, landowners, developers, environmental NGOs, councils and recreational users. We also examined a large archive on the history of flood and drainage works affecting the estuary.  

We found that while marine science was important in developing the restoration strategy, the planning process was ultimately a social and political activity. A social science perspective allowed us to uncover these dynamics, showing how politics, ideas and engagement strategies all contributed to the outcome. The reason the strategy was successful was that it provided the opportunity for multiple perspectives to be heard and fostered mutual learning among participants and the development of a common vision.  

The case provides noteworthy examples of local traditional knowledge being incorporated into technical designs, improving the likelihood of effective outcomes. These insights suggest scientists and engineers engaged in planning processes will be more effective acting as informed facilitators than subject experts.

Related News

Project proposal

711 KB | pdf

Location

Tools & Resources

This project has produced or contributed to:

Community participation in the development of the Ōngātoro/Maketū Estuary project: The socio-ecological dimensions of restoring an interconnected ecosystem
Academic publication
Barrett P, Kurian P, Simmonds N & Cretney R (2019) Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 1-14
View
Explaining reflexive governance through discursive institutionalism: estuarine restoration in Aotearoa New Zealand
Academic publication
P Barrett, P Kurian, N Simmonds & R Cretney (2021). Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 23:3, 332-344
View
Participatory processes and the evolution of environmental agendas in estuary restoration: the Maketū case
Academic publication
This article analyses participatory processes in estuary restoration in Maketū on the East Coast of the North Island to examine how evolving relational dynamics amongst key stakeholders and Māori led to the achievement of a collective environmental imaginary. Barrett P, Kurian P, Cretney R, Blackett P, Le Heron E, & Le Heron, R (June 2022)
View

Related projects & activities

Image
Frameworks for achieving and maintaining social licence
We investigated the use of the term ‘social licence’ in Aotearoa New Zealand and what factors influence social licence.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Paula Blackett
Testing participatory processes for marine management
We identified the best ways to involve interested parties in decision-making about the governance and management of marine environments.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: Dave Allen NIWA
Development of valuation frameworks and principles
We identified frameworks and principles for recognising the multiple values of the marine environment to support EBM.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Credit: NZ Story/Chris Williams
EBM within Aotearoa New Zealand’s existing legislative framework
We investigated how well EBM aligns with Aotearoa New Zealand’s legislation, policy and governance relating to the marine environment.
More
This project has produced or contributed to
Image
Hui-te-ana-nui: Understanding kaitiakitanga in our marine environment
We have examined mātauranga Māori associated with the marine environment by analysing key texts, historical archives, literature, reports and legislation.
More
This project has produced or contributed to